Putting together a lineup is one of skills that a manager must demonstrate throughout the course of a season. He must balance all of his hitters while ensuring that the players hitting both in front of a player and behind a player each serve a role in doing so. The task is traditionally made easier by the fact that most teams have at least a few weaker hitters who will naturally hit towards the bottom of the lineup. So how does a manager put together a lineup for an all star game in which there are no "token" hitters for any spot in the lineup? With that said, I will attempt to put together the starting lineups for tomorrow night's All Star Game, taking into account both skill and managerial preference/loyalty. (Note - I'm trying to keep up to date on all of the injury updates).
NL:
SS Ramirez - No longer Florida's leadoff hitter but on a team of All Stars he best serves this role.
3B Wright - High OBP and SB potential make him ideal for this spot
1B Pujols - No explanation needed.
DH Votto - He won the final vote, but should have made the team on account of his peers.
RF Holliday - Should be Charlie Manuel's pick to fill in for Jason Heyward.
CF Ethier -
LF Braun - Not a great year for Braun but certainly still productive.
2B Prado - No Chase Utley, but a surprise performer this year.
C Molina - By far the weakest hitter. The Molina brothers' father apparently only gave hitting lessons to Bengie and I have a feeling those lessons were not as thorough as they could have been.
AL:
CF Ichiro - As if there was anyone else who would hit lead off. I could be wrong but he has probably lead off every single All Star Game that he has started (which means every All Star Game dating back to 2001).
SS Jeter - Not statistically deserving of this spot this year but he's the Yankee captain, a former All Star Game MVP, and his manager is writing out the lineup.
RF Hamilton - He's back to his 2008 form, as he is among league leaders in average, homers, and rbis. A strong second half could push him into triple crown contention.
DH Guerrero - In a left-handed heavy lineup he breaks up the left-handed hitters.
1B Cabrera - He's filling in for the injured Justin Morneau but could easily have been voted in as the starter. Phenomenal hitter and rbi machine.
2B Cano - Breaks up the string of righty hitters.
3B Longoria -Really wouldn't hit him any lower.
C Mauer - Crazy, I know, but he's not hitting for power this year.
LF Crawford - Should probably be hitting second but as I said, with Jeter on the team and Girardi managing, not a chance Jeter is hitting down in the lineup.
So that's my lineup. What's yours?